Sausage and Pepper

This is such a versatile mix. It can be eaten on its own, as a sandwich, or as a pasta dish. The inspiration for this dish comes from Musumeci’s Deli. Let me set the scene for a second. A good friend of ours that I used to work with first introduce me to Mucumeci’s Deli when we worked together. One day as we are going to lunch he suggest this little sandwich shop he knows. As we drive to the center of the city, passing by all of the big beautiful buildings he turns down an alley, and pulls into a small parking lot behind what appears to be an abandoned building. With a huge grin on his face he gets out and we walk in to the building. The lobby is full of tables and plastic lawn chairs, and to the side there is a small shop that has a line out the door and part way through the lobby. We get into the line and working our way into the shop, where my friend grabs some papers and pens off of the counter and says, “Fill this out correctly or you have to go to the back of the line.” The inside of the shop is basically a small kitchen, with microwaves, pots of boiling water, stacks of fresh sub rolls on at the back. Two men are working in the kitchen, the younger one one taking the orders and money, the older putting orders together. This turns out to be an Italian kitchen, in all that you picture with that, the two men were father and son both named Phil. The food ranged from the Musumeci Special (ham, turkey and cheese with all the fixings) to cheese manicotti with Colosimo’s Italian sausage, and everything was so good, even the Cherry Coke was adjusted to cherry perfection. Hidden in the menu was the sausage and pepper sandwich, green peppers and onions sauteed together, placed on their special sub rolls with either mild or hot Italian sausage (grilled and sliced lengthwise). No marinara or cheese added. Just the addictive goodness.

This became a standard for me and every time I would go with my friend the orders were the same One full Musumeci Special and one full Sausage and Pepper Hot. This is also where I was introduced to the savior of the lunch order quandary, “the Splitter”. Half of each sandwich swapped.

Okay so after years of going to Musumeci’s deli and being well and truly addicted to the Sausage and Pepper sandwich, the worst thing possible happened. We walk in to the deli and Pops and Phil tell us that the City informed them that they would not renew the lease for the shop and were closing them down. I took my family there one last time and said good bye to the best sandwich I have ever eaten… Until now.

Through the next few years I would get the craving and shrug it off. Then after years of getting the shakes and yearning for Sausage and Pepper, we determined that we would duplicate the recipe and like all of our recipes, many trial and errors later we came up with this. Now it is not perfect but it is really close!

We triple the recipe when we do it so we get three meals out of it. We like to do one package of HOT Italian Sausage and two packages of Mild Italian Sausage. We have also done one package HOT Italian Sausage, one package Mild Italian Sausage, and one package Sweet Italian Sausage.  We Food Seal the left overs to use within 2-3 months.


3 Green Bell Peppers
2 T Olive Oil
1 Yellow Onion
2 T Olive Oil
2-3 Fresh Basil Leaves chopped
1 T Italian Seasoning
1 pk Italian Sausage

1 Jar Marinara
Grated Parmesan Cheese


Slice peppers and onions.

Grill Italian Sausages.

Saute Peppers in a cast iron skillet with 2 T Olive Oil. Caramelize Onion in 2 T Olive Oil. Combine peppers and onions.

Add chopped basil to the peppers and onions and simmer for 5 minutes. Add Italian Seasoning and simmer for an additional 5 minutes.

Slice sausage and stir in to the pepper and onion mix.

Serve with Marinara and Grated Parmesan Cheese.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.